Managing Campus Unrest: An Enterprise Risk Management Perspective on Student Protests Concerning Gaza

Tuesday, May 07, 2024

The One Minute Risk Manager/ERM/Managing Campus Unrest: An Enterprise Risk Management Perspective on Student Protests Concerning Gaza
one minute manager jfif

University campuses have long been arenas for political expression and activism, often mirroring the broader societal and global issues. The student protests concerning Gaza are a poignant example of how international conflicts can influence campus dynamics, presenting university leadership with a multifaceted challenge. From an enterprise risk management (ERM) perspective, these protests are not just about managing immediate disruptions but also about understanding the deeper political implications and their potential impact on leadership stability.

Understanding the Risks

1. Political Pressure:
Protests about highly political topics like the Gaza conflict can attract attention from beyond the campus borders, involving local, state, and even national politicians. Universities may find themselves at the center of a political storm, with external pressures dictating or influencing their response strategies. This can complicate decision-making processes and amplify the risks associated with taking any particular stance.

2. Leadership Vulnerability:
In politically charged environments, university leaders are often scrutinized for their actions or inactions. Decisions made during times of crisis can define a leader’s tenure, influencing perceptions of their capability and alignment with institutional values. The call for leadership changes or resignations can escalate if stakeholders — including students, faculty, donors, and the broader public — perceive that leaders have mishandled the situation.

3. Reputational Risk:
Reputational risk is significant. The political dimensions of student protests can exacerbate this, as the university’s handling of the situation may be viewed through a political lens. A perceived alignment with either side of the political spectrum can alienate parts of the university’s community or the public, potentially leading to long-term reputational damage.

4. Financial Implications:
These are also compounded by the political nature of the protests. Political backlash from influential donors or government bodies, depending on the perceived position of the university, can lead to financial repercussions. This is particularly critical in an era where funding is increasingly tied to political and social considerations.

Strategies for Risk Management

1. Balanced Political Engagement:
University leadership must navigate the political landscape carefully, engaging with political figures and influences without compromising the institution’s autonomy or values. This involves a clear, principled stance that respects the diversity of the university community and adheres to its core mission of fostering academic freedom and integrity.

2. Transparent and Inclusive Decision-Making:
Decisions should be made transparently and include inputs from a broad range of campus stakeholders. This not only enhances the legitimacy of the decisions taken but also helps in managing political pressures by demonstrating a commitment to democratic values and community engagement.

3. Robust Crisis Management and Communication:
The political implications of campus protests necessitate a robust crisis management strategy that includes effective communication. Keeping all stakeholders informed and engaged helps mitigate the risk of misinformation and misunderstanding that can fuel political and social tensions.

4. Leadership Continuity Planning:
Given the vulnerability of leadership positions in politically sensitive situations, universities should have a continuity plan that addresses potential leadership transitions. This planning should be part of the broader risk management strategy, ensuring that the university can maintain stability and direction even amidst calls for resignations or leadership changes.

The intersection of enterprise risk management and political strategy is crucial in managing campus unrest related to global political issues like the Gaza conflict. University leadership must be adept not only at managing immediate risks but also at navigating the complex political repercussions that such protests can engender. By employing a strategy that combines risk management with political savvy, universities can protect their reputations, ensure financial stability, and maintain their commitments to academic freedom and integrity, even in times of crisis.

Don't want to miss the next issue?

1 png

Save Time and Money

Bundle and save!! Get access to all three courses (ARM 400, 401, and 402) for the price of two.

ARM(™) and CPCU ® are trademarks of the American Institute For Chartered Property Casualty Underwriters, d/b/a The Institutes.

Erike Young is a recognized course leader for The Institutes content but not affiliated or associated with The Institutes in any way. The Institutes do not explicitly endorse, approve, or support Erike Young or The Risk Management Study Group’s services, but approve of the use of our materials for educational purposes.